Back in July, Sir Brian Leveson (a former Lord Justice of Appeal) published the first part of his
Independent Review of the Criminal Courts. Initial thoughts about the
report may be read in the
previous post 6 July 2025.
Independent Review of the Criminal Courts Part 1 (pdf 388 pages). Part 2 of the report - (Efficiency) - continues to be awaited.
On Tuesday 2 November 2025, the Secretary of State for Justice (Mr David Lammy MP) announced to the House of Commons the government's proposals for criminal justice reforms - see Hansard 2 December.
At this point we can note that indictable-only offences (i.e. triable ONLY in the Crown Court) will continue to be tried with juries. There are many such offences including murder, manslaughter, causing death by dangerous driving, robbery, aggravated burglary etc.
An exception will be 'exceptionally technical and lengthy fraud and financial
trials' where judges will be able to sit without a jury where appropriate. Lammy said - 'While those cases are small in number, they place undue pressure on
jurors to sit for months—a significant interference with their personal
and professional lives.' Naturally one wonders whether that reasoning will come to apply to other types of case - e.g. cases involving difficult forensic or medical evidence etc.
Many offences are "triable either-way" -